Solar air heater, heat pump, butane or electric radiator: which to choose

Advantages, limitations and when it makes sense to combine them

When the cold arrives, the question is always the same: what should I heat my home, garage or second home with? In this article we compare the solar air heater with the three most common options: the heat pump, the butane heater and the electric radiator. The aim is not to pick an absolute winner, but to understand what each one does well and when it makes sense to combine them.

Solar air heater

A south-facing collector captures the sun's radiation and heats the air inside it; a small fan pushes it into the room through a flexible duct.

  • Advantages: the heat comes from the sun, it only uses the fan's electricity, burns nothing, needs no building work and supplies dry air that helps against damp.
  • Limitations: it only heats when the sun is out; at night or on overcast days it provides no heat. It needs a south-facing wall or roof.
  • Ideal for: garages, workshops, second homes, greenhouses, basements and as a back-up in homes with cold but sunny winters.

Heat pump (air-to-water or air conditioning with heat pump)

It extracts heat from the outdoor air and brings it indoors using electricity. For every unit of electricity it consumes, it delivers several units of heat, which is why it is very efficient.

  • Advantages: it works day and night, it is efficient and many units also cool in summer.
  • Limitations: it requires a larger investment and professional installation, and its performance drops at very low outdoor temperatures.
  • Ideal for: homes lived in all year round, as the main heating.

Butane heater

It burns gas inside the room itself to produce heat.

  • Advantages: it gives a lot of heat quickly, is portable and needs no installation.
  • Limitations: you have to buy and change the gas bottles, it consumes the oxygen in the room and produces water vapour, which increases damp and condensation. It needs ventilation and safety precautions.
  • Ideal for: occasional heat in well-ventilated spaces.

Electric radiator or storage heater

It converts electricity directly into heat.

  • Advantages: cheap to buy, no installation, clean and quiet.
  • Limitations: every unit of heat costs one unit of electricity, so with continuous use you notice it on the bill.
  • Ideal for: small rooms and use for a few hours.

Quick comparison

Solar airHeat pumpButaneElectric radiator
Energy sourceSun (+ fan)ElectricityGasElectricity
Works at nightNoYesYesYes
Effect on dampDries the airNeutralIncreases itNeutral
Combustion in the roomNoNoYesNo
InstallationSimple, no building workProfessionalNoneNone

The best option is usually to combine them

The solar air heater does not compete with the main heating: it complements it. During sunny hours it provides heat and dry air at almost no cost, so the heat pump, the heater or the radiator run for fewer hours. In spaces used during the day or that mainly need drying out, such as a garage, a workshop or a house closed during the week, it may be enough on its own.

For reference, in our January test in Valladolid, with a perceived outdoor temperature of 2 °C, the air left the collector at 40 °C. You can see in which spaces it pays off most and how to install it.

Not sure what suits you?

Tell us which space you want to heat and what you heat it with now, and we will tell you whether the solar air heater is a good fit. You can also see the prices and reserve yours with a €50 deposit.

Ask about my case or call us on 686 227 287.

Share this post